Law Firm Website Redesign: When to Do It and How to Keep Your Rankings

Not every old law firm site needs a full redesign. Learn when to fix, refresh or redesign, what to keep, and how to protect your rankings with a small-firm plan.
Last updated:

November 17, 2026

Law Firm Website Redesign: When to Do It and How to Keep Your Rankings

Table of contents

    A law firm website redesign makes sense when the site’s structure, platform or content stops it from bringing in inquiries, not just when it looks dated. If the problems are a few slow pages, old copy or a weak contact path, a refresh is usually enough. If you do redesign, map every old URL to a new one with permanent redirects, so the pages that bring in clients keep their search visibility.

    This guide is for solo attorneys and small firms of 2 to 10 lawyers. It starts with the decision, then gives you a six-phase plan sized for a small site.

    Key takeaways

    • Decide first: fix, refresh or redesign.
    • Most of the work is content, not design.
    • Keep, rewrite, merge or retire every page on purpose.
    • Redirect every old URL that has traffic or links, and keep the redirects for at least a year.
    • Re-check results, reviews and disclaimers against your rules before launch.

    Does your law firm need a website redesign, or just a refresh?

    You need a full redesign when the problem is the site’s foundation: a platform you can’t edit, a structure that hides your practice areas, or no real mobile layout. If the foundation works and only the content or look is tired, a refresh costs less and carries less risk.

    Here is what each option means:

    • Fix: repair specific problems on the current site, such as a broken form or slow images.
    • Refresh: keep the structure and platform, and update copy, photos, visual style and key pages.
    • Redesign: new structure and design, often a new platform, and usually new URLs.
    Symptom Fix Refresh Redesign
    Contact form fails or the phone number isn’t tappable on mobile ✓ – –
    A few pages load slowly because of large images ✓ – –
    Attorney bios, photos and copy are out of date, but visitors find things easily – ✓ –
    The site looks dated, but you can edit it and the navigation works – ✓ –
    Your practice areas changed and the menu no longer matches what you do – – ✓
    You can’t edit the site yourself, or the developer who built it is gone – – ✓
    There is no real mobile layout – – ✓
    Visitors can’t find the practice area they came for – – ✓

    If most rows land in the first two columns, you probably don’t need a full design project. A freelancer or your current developer can often handle fixes and a refresh. For a full audit of what is working and what isn’t, use our website UX audit checklist.

    Signs your law firm website needs a redesign

    Most signs your law firm website needs a redesign are about structure and content, not looks:

    • You depend on someone else for every change. If updating a bio or adding a practice page means a support ticket, the platform is holding you back.
    • The structure buries your practice areas. A visitor with a specific legal problem should reach the right page in one or two taps.
    • The site wasn’t built for phones. Shrinking a desktop layout is not the same as designing for mobile.
    • Your firm has changed. New practice areas, new partners or a new office often don’t fit the old navigation.
    • The intake path is broken or unclear. Forms that go nowhere, missing calls to action or a contact page buried in the footer cost you inquiries.
    • The content doesn’t answer basic hiring questions. Clio’s 2024 secret shopper study of 500 law firms found only 30% of firm websites gave clear guidance on the hiring process, and only 14% showed pricing (Clio). A redesign is the moment to fix the content, not just the look.

    What a small-firm redesign actually involves

    For most solo and small firms, a redesign covers a short list of core pages, and most of the effort goes into content. Design and build matter, but the step that usually takes longest is writing, reviewing and approving the copy.

    A typical small-firm site comes down to a few page groups: home, practice areas, attorney bios, About, contact, and supporting content such as results, reviews and blog posts. You may have more pages than that, but they usually fall into those groups.

    Illustrative scenario. A three-lawyer family law firm has an old site with outdated bios, a handful of practice pages and years of short news posts. In the redesign, the firm keeps its practice area URLs and rewrites the copy, updates every bio, merges thin news posts into a few useful guides, and rebuilds the contact page around one clear intake form.

    Large firms with many offices and hundreds of pages need a longer, more technical project than this.

    Your law firm website redesign checklist, phase by phase

    A small-firm redesign fits into six phases: benchmark, content inventory, URL map, design and build, rules and accessibility review, then launch and monitor. Use this law firm website redesign checklist as your project outline, and don’t start design until the first three phases are done.

    Phase 1: Benchmark the current site

    Before you change anything, export your top pages by traffic, your inquiries and form fills, and the search queries that bring visitors in from Google Search Console.

    Also record your Core Web Vitals. Google’s web.dev defines “good” as Largest Contentful Paint within 2.5 seconds, Interaction to Next Paint within 200 milliseconds and Cumulative Layout Shift below 0.1, measured at the 75th percentile of page loads.

    Phase 2: Take a content inventory

    List every page on the current site and decide its fate: keep, rewrite, merge or retire. The table in the next section shows the usual action for each law firm page type.

    Phase 3: Build the URL map

    List every old URL and the new URL it will point to, before the build starts. The rankings section below covers the details.

    Phase 4: Design and build

    Plan the information architecture first: which pages exist, how they connect and what the navigation shows. Then design for mobile first, so the site works for visitors who arrive on a phone. Give each practice area its own clear page, and make the intake path obvious from every page: one primary action, a short form and a tappable phone number.

    Phase 5: Review rules and accessibility

    Check every claim, result and review on the new site against your professional rules (see who signs off below). Then check accessibility. The US Department of Justice says the ADA applies to the websites of businesses open to the public and points to the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines as helpful guidance (ADA.gov). Useful WCAG 2.2 checks include text contrast of at least 4.5:1, click and tap targets of at least 24 by 24 CSS pixels, and labels on form fields where input is required.

    Phase 6: Launch and monitor

    On launch day, switch on the redirects, submit your new sitemap in Search Console and test every form. Over the following weeks, watch indexing, crawl errors and inquiries, and compare them to your Phase 1 benchmark.

    What should you keep from your old law firm website?

    Keep any page that brings in traffic, links or inquiries, even if its content needs a full rewrite. Keeping the URL is often more valuable than keeping the words. Retire only pages that are outdated, duplicated or no longer true.

    Page type Usual action Why
    Practice area pages Keep the URL, rewrite the content These pages often hold much of your search visibility. The copy usually needs to answer client questions more clearly.
    Attorney bios Rewrite, keep the URL Clients and referrers often look up a lawyer by name. Update roles, bar admissions and photos.
    Case results Re-check against your rules, then keep or retire Old results can become misleading without context. Retire any you can’t stand behind today.
    Old blog or news posts Keep what gets traffic, merge thin posts, retire outdated ones Short, dated news items rarely help. Merging related posts into one guide makes each page stronger.
    Location pages Keep only where you actually serve clients A page for an office you closed or an area you don’t serve is misleading.
    Contact page Rebuild This is where inquiries happen. Design it around one clear form and direct contact options.

    How to redesign a law firm website without losing rankings

    Map every old URL to its closest new page, use server-side permanent redirects, and keep them for at least a year. Some ranking movement after launch is normal, so plan for it rather than expecting none.

    Google’s site move guidance says to map old URLs to new ones, use server-side permanent redirects, avoid long redirect chains and keep redirects for at least a year. It also notes that rankings can fluctuate for a while during a move. So the honest answer to how you redesign a law firm website without losing rankings is this: redirects protect most of the visibility you have earned and help it transfer, but they don’t freeze your positions.

    The steps:

    1. Map every URL that has traffic or links. Use your Phase 1 export so nothing important is missed.
    2. Use 301 or 308 redirects. Google treats these as permanent and shows the new URL in results. With 302, 303 or 307 redirects, Google keeps showing the old page (Google Search Central).
    3. Point each old page to its closest match. Don’t send everything to the homepage.
    4. Avoid chains. Redirect old URLs straight to the final page, not through older redirects.
    5. Keep the redirects for at least a year, longer if you can.
    6. Use Search Console after launch. If the domain changes, verify both sites. Submit the new sitemap and watch for crawl errors. The Change of Address tool applies only to a new domain or subdomain.

    Illustrative URL map:

    Old URL New URL Action
    /divorce-lawyer.html /practice-areas/divorce/ 301 redirect
    /our-team/jane-smith /attorneys/jane-smith/ 301 redirect
    /news/2017-office-party (none) Retire, redirect to /blog/ only if it has links
    /practice-areas/divorce/ /practice-areas/divorce/ Unchanged, no redirect needed

    Who does what: your firm vs your designer

    Your firm owns the facts and the rules sign-off. Your designer owns structure, user experience and design. Whoever builds the site owns the redirects and launch checks.

    Task Your firm Designer Developer or designer-builder
    Practice area facts, bios and case details Supplies and approves Shapes into clear pages
    Copy for each page Reviews and approves Drafts or edits (if in scope)
    Rules review of claims, results and reviews Signs off Flags anything that looks risky
    Site structure and navigation Approves Plans
    Visual design and intake path Approves Designs
    URL map Confirms which pages matter Plans new URLs Sets up redirects
    Accessibility checks Designs to WCAG Tests on the built site
    Launch QA and monitoring Tests forms and contact details Reviews the live pages Runs technical checks

    Not legal advice. ABA Model Rule 7.1 says lawyers must not make false or misleading communications about their services, including by leaving out facts. It is a model rule: each state adopts its own version, and some states require ads to be filed or reviewed. Lawyers in Canada, Australia, the UK and the EU answer to separate regulators. Check your own regulator’s rules, and have a lawyer at your firm approve results, reviews, “specialist” wording and disclaimers before launch.

    How does Convex approach a law firm website redesign?

    We are founder-led, so the person you talk to is the person who designs your site. Every project has a fixed scope, quoted upfront, so you know what you’re getting before work starts.

    We work in four stages: discovery and understanding, strategy and planning, design and iteration, and handoff and support. Discovery comes before design because it reduces surprises later, especially around content and page structure. We design in Figma and build Framer websites end to end.

    If you start from a template, we treat it as a starting point, not a finished design. After launch, sites tend to need ongoing updates and small improvements, and our Care plan for Framer sites costs $320/month.

    We also design for the legal space beyond websites, such as the LawSphere legal case management dashboard.

    FAQ

    Will a law firm website redesign hurt my rankings?

    Some temporary ranking movement is normal after a redesign, and Google says to expect fluctuation during a site move. Mapping every old URL to its closest new page with permanent redirects helps most of your visibility carry over.

    How long does a law firm website redesign take?

    It depends mostly on how ready your content is, because writing and approving copy is often the longest part. At Convex, a Framer website takes 20–30 days.

    Should I change platforms when I redesign?

    It can be a good time to switch if you can’t edit your current site, but a platform change usually means new URLs, so the redirect plan matters even more. Our WordPress to Framer migration guide covers the process.

    How long should I keep redirects?

    Keep them for at least a year, and longer if you can. Google recommends keeping redirects in place as long as possible.

    Do I need to rewrite all my content?

    No. Keep pages that bring in traffic and inquiries, rewrite outdated practice pages and bios, merge thin posts and retire anything that is no longer true.

    Who checks the new site against bar rules?

    The lawyers at your firm. A designer can flag claims that look risky, but only your firm can approve them under your regulator’s rules. This is not legal advice.

    How much does a law firm website redesign cost?

    It depends on the number of pages, how much content needs rewriting and the platform. At Convex, Framer websites start from $2,200, with the scope fixed and quoted upfront.

    Start your law firm website redesign with a decision, not a mood board

    Fix what is broken, refresh what is tired, and redesign only when the structure, platform or content stops the site from bringing in inquiries. If you do go ahead, protect what you’ve earned with a URL map and permanent redirects, and get your rules sign-off before launch.

    Not sure which one your site needs? Get a free UX audit of your current site, with no commitment. We’ll tell you whether a fix, a refresh or a full redesign makes sense.

    You can also see how we work with law firms on our legal industry page.

    Akib Ahmad

    Akib Ahmad

    Co-founder & CEO

    Akib Ahmad is the co-founder and CEO of Convex, a UI/UX design and web development agency for startups and growing businesses. He has 4+ years of experience designing websites, mobile apps, dashboards and MVPs, including in-house product work at EdTech and InsurTech startups and client projects in e-commerce, real estate and fitness. He writes about product design, UX and what it really takes to launch digital products that users enjoy and businesses can grow with.